Argument From Ignorance

by Jonathan Leeming January 31, 2018

Although we as humans consider ourselves as superior beings, we suffer from several flaws of the human mind. These flaws propagate sightings of the Yeti, Elvis, the Loch Ness monster and occurrences spider bites.

Argument from ignorance is not a unique feature of the easily fooled, but a a phenomenon that occurs in every culture and regardless of intellect, ideology and upbringing.

So why do so many people think they have been bitten by a spider when there is no evidence to suggest that a spider was involved?

Russell’s Teapot

In 1952 philosopher Bertrand Russell put forward an idea that there is a tea pot orbiting the solar system, somewhere between the Earth and Mars. This teapot is too small to be detected using any instrument nor can it be seen through any telescope! Since the tea pot is undetectable, it is impossible to prove that it does not exist.

Russell’s teapot teaches us that an absence of evidence that the tea pots existence, is more likely to infer that the tea pot does not exist, rather than it could exist. Of course common sense dictates that it is highly improbable that this undetectable tea pot is out there, but we cannot prove it beyond a shadow of doubt!

It is impossible to prove that something does not exist, only that it is probably unlikely to exist. This probability is based upon our knowledge of the facts and understanding on the subject. For example we cannot prove that Santa Clause, the abominable snowman, Loch Ness Monster do not exist.

Russell’s tea pot helps us understand why spider bite misdiagnosis is rife. In the absence of any evidence that a lesion is the result of a “spider bite”, we should not assume that a spider is to blame.

In a situation where there is a lack of evidence that a spider was responsible for a lesion or bite like appearance, it should never be assumed that a spider was responsible.

The rise of social media has given a platform to this mindset. Like minded beings can band together to collectively convince themselves of factually unrealistic events.

Many people think they have been bitten by a spider. This conclusion is based upon a lack of knowledge and a lack of evidence.

Jonathan Leeming

Jonathan Leeming is a best selling author, international speaker and award winning conservationist. He has written 9 books (Scorpions of southern Africa, Scorpions of Sabi Sands, Spider & Scorpion Risk Assessment, Venomous Animal General Awareness, Risk Assessment & First Aid, Antivenom Management, General Awareness, First Aid Guide To Spider Bites & Scorpion Stings). 

He consults for the Poison Information Helpline, various organisations and speaks at medical conferences on the subject of envenomation.  Jonathan brings a fresh and unique insight into the subject of venomous animals and their bites and stings.
Jonathan is a proud recipient of a 2020 Eco-Logic Environmental award for his One World Book and associated presentations, workshops, activities and free resources.

If you run an organisation or community group and would like an event, then email me on info@JonathanLeeming.com I offer generous discounts for community groups, and can arrange an event at your venue, or arrange a venue. Events are priced according to your budget and requirements. 

Do you have your own group and want your own event?

linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram